Statement by Sandra Steingraber about the CBS Evening News Report

As the scientist featured in the August 19 CBS story, “New York State to Allow Fracking,” I am shocked at both the headline and the unsourced claim that “New York is about to okay fracking, and will issue guidelines after Labor Day.”

Just twelve days earlier, Governor Cuomo said that no decision had yet been made as to whether he would permit or prohibit hydraulic fracking in New York State because, “we are waiting for the [Department of Conservation] to finish its final report and that hasn’t happened yet.”  On the same day, DEC chief Joe Martens corroborated the governor in a statement of his own, saying, “There is still more work to be done” and “there is no firm timetable.”  As recently as this past Wednesday, Governor Cuomo said that DEC is still in the middle of their review on fracking.

If the Governor is truly basing his decision on science, as he has said repeatedly to the press, then how can there be a pre-determined timeline? Is horizontal hydraulic fracturing in New York State to be greenlighted on the basis of a politically calculated date or on the still unfinished process of scientific investigation, as the Governor has promised?

Throughout the shale gas drilling review process, independent scientists—along with physicians, economists, elected officials, and business leaders—have attempted to bring before both the governor and senior DEC officials serious unaddressed concerns about fracking.  These range from public health effects and toxic wastewater disposal to well casing failures and radon.  At every turn, our communiqués have gone unanswered, even while gas industry representatives have enjoyed reciprocal conversationswith DEC staff and sneak peeks at draft regulations unseen by the rest of us. In light of this one-sided access, the CBS story is one more indication that industry influence and bad faith are driving the biggest environmental decision in the history of New York State.

As the signatory to several of these letters, I assure the governor that many of us are prepared to be public with our discontent and will not be patient with attempts to create a fait accompli.

–Sandra Steingraber, PhD, Distinguished Scholar in Residence, Ithaca College; co-founder, New Yorkers Against Fracking

No Comments Yet.

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.